
In LEGO Adventures! Magazine Issue 3, the Brickster was robbing a bank vault when his robbery was revealed by clumsy construction workers who accidentally knocked a hole in the wall of a bank. In the opening cutscene when Rocket Racer picks up a paper reporting his race in LEGO Racers, and a picture on the back of the paper shows the Brickster behind bars. The Brickster makes a cameo in LEGO Racers 2. The Brickster is seen clutching a key at the end. Once the Brickster's team was defeated, The Brickster was "safely" locked in the Spaceship hold, after it set off again from Mars. The Brickster then assembled a football team of his own to play against the player. The player discovered the Brickster again on Mars, and had to play against the Martian team and the Brickster-Bot team. Eventually they discovered that he had escaped in a Spaceship and as a result had to win more matches in order to unlock a spaceship. The player's team then had to hunt down the Brickster while playing football matches along the way. After the player's team had won the first few matches, the team was to be awarded with a trophy, but the Brickster appeared and stole the trophy, then disappeared. The Brickster, like in the LEGO Island series, is the main antagonist in Soccer Mania. Once in prison, he found something and began to laugh. He was given yet another chance to be free, but he refused. Once defeated, the Brickster was captured. The last was to call up Brickster bots to push Pepper off the edge. The second granted him super speed, where he would run at high speeds toward the center. The first was one where he would jump on the ground, sending out a shockwave, but it made him vulnerable to being thrown off the edge. The Brickster had five lives and three different powers. After avoiding the obstacles and racing to the top of the mountain, Pepper had to face off against the Brickster. He kidnapped the Infomaniac, went to the top of the mountain, and began dropping objects around the island. After Pepper filmed the parachuting scene, the Brickster revealed that his involvement in the film was merely a cover for his evil plan: using Brickster Bots to build a tower from which he could deconstruct the world. He helped Pepper film the action scenes for the movie, taking the place of the bad guy. In Island Xtreme Stunts, the Brickster promised to reform in order to be let out of jail. After a short battle, the Brickster was once again defeated by pizzas thrown by Pepper but this time was imprisoned in a small tower on Ogel. Eventually, Pepper Roni was able to collect all the missing pages of the Constructopedia and journey to Ogel to defeat the Brickster, who had kidnapped Mama and Papa Brickolini so that he could have pizzas whenever he wished. He then called the Brickster bots from Ogel Island to harass the people of LEGO Island while he escaped back to Ogel. Shortly after, he stole the Constructopedia from the Information Center and tore out its pages (destroying the buildings in LEGO Island) and scattered them across the world. Once he had enough peppers, he ate them all and used his "Brickster dragon breath" to melt to door of the jail and escape (again). He had many pizzas delivered to him (although he wasn't allowed anything with more than one pepper) and saved the peppers. In LEGO Island 2, after being in jail for some time, the Brickster began his long-winded plan to escape. He was then imprisoned in the new LEGO Island jail.

Once the helicopter was complete, Pepper captured the Brickster by shooting pizzas at him, distracting the Brickster and allowing him to then be caught by Nick Brick. Pepper Roni was sent out to retrieve the parts for the police helicopter, which the Brickster had hidden throughout the island. He proceeded to terrorize the island by stealing the buildings and the bricks that make them up. The Brickster then stole the Power Brick atop of the Information Center and the Ambulance. He used the pizza to melt the lock to his jail cell and then took the nearby helicopter. He made a call to the local pizzeria to order one of Papa Brickolini's ultra hot and spicy pizzas, posing as Nick Brick. Sometime between the events of the Brickster's departure from LEGO Island and the start of the game, the Brickster was imprisoned in the LEGO Island jail.
